From science, moral-poetics: Dr. James Dobson's response to the fetal tissue research initiative

Journal/Book: Quart J Speech. 2000; 86: 5105 Backlick Rd, Annandale, VA 22003, USA. Speech Communication Assn. 146-167.

Abstract: This essay analyzes a letter written by James Dobson to over 2 million constituents of Focus on the Family. The letter discusses the 1993 Fetal Tissue Research Initiative, and is a complex example of moral-poetic discourse rising above the scientific ideal in American culture. I first employ a judgmental analysis to determine what Dobson's potential reading audience was being asked to believe. Second, using Kenneth Burke's distinction between semantic and poetic meaning I examine Dobson's discourse as a moral-poetic response to the amoral stance of scientific discourse. Finally, I analyze the motive underpinning Dobson's discourse to understand the actions of Dobson's envisioned moral agent. This study found that Dobson Provided a way out of the moral quagmire science has placed humans in by highlighting mankind's ability to morally act, thereby initiating an individual-moral redemptive cycle.

Note: Article Kuypers JA, Dartmouth Coll, Off Speech, 6046 Bartlett Hall, Hanover,NH 03755 USA

Keyword(s): judgmental analysis; motive; moral-poetic meaning; partial birth abortion; semantic meaning

Zurück | Weiter