Mentally deranged and dangerous? Attitudes of journalists and medical students

Author(s): Holzinger, A.

Journal/Book: Psychiat Prax. 2000; 27: Rudigerstr 14, D-70469 Stuttgart, Germany. Georg Thieme Verlag Kg. 336-339.

Abstract: Objective: The realisation of community mental health services may be adversely affected by society's prejudices about mentally disordered people. In this regard, the frequently replicated stereotype that people with mental illness are dangerous is of paramount relevance. Methods: journalists and medical students were asked by means of an interview whether they consider certain crimes (murder, rape, arson, larceny, disorderly conduct) to be more frequently committed by mentally disordered persons or by the general population or whether no difference is supposed. Results: journalists and medical students agreed about the frequency of commitment concerning offences such as murder (no difference between the mentally disordered and the general population), arson (more frequently committed by mentally disordered persons) and larceny (more frequently committed by the general population). While almost half the journalists supposed that there is no difference between mentally disordered persons and the general population regarding rape and disorderly conduct, just as much medical students charged mentally disordered persons with these offences. Personal contact to people with mental disorders slightly influenced these attitudes to the credit of mentally disordered persons. Conclusions: Compared with the results of a representative survey among the general population of the old Under of Germany in 1990, journalists asked in our investigation markedly less often charged mentally disordered people with murder, rape and disorderly conduct. Medical students, in contrast, shared the general population's attitude except for murder.

Note: Article Gutierrez-Lobos K, Univ Vienna, Psychiat Klin, Abt Sozialpsychiat & Evaluat Forsch, Waehringer Guertel 18-20, A-1090 Vienna, AUSTRIA

Keyword(s): PRINTED MEDIA; SCHIZOPHRENIA; ILL; PSYCHIATRY; PEOPLE

Zurück | Weiter