Don't eat the daisies: Disinterestedness and the situated aesthetic

Journal/Book: Environ Value. 1998; 7: 1 Strond, Isle of Harris PA83 3UD, Scotland. White Horse Press. 97-114.

Abstract: In debates about nature conservation, aesthetic appreciation is typically understood in terms of valuing nature as an amenity, something that we value for the pleasure it provides. In this paper I argue that this position, what I call the hedonistic model, rests on a misunderstanding of aesthetic appreciation. To support this claim I put forward an alternative model based on disinterestedness, and I defend disinterestedness against mistaken interpretations of it. Properly understood, disinterestedness defines a standpoint which precludes self-interest and utility, and it does not entail a passive subject abstracted from who they are. This standpoint is compatible with a 'situated aesthetic' in which appreciation of aesthetic qualities is grounded in an embedded subject who is sensitive to the context and narrative of the object. The alternative model provides a conception of aesthetic value which distinguishes it from amenity value, and it also defines a non-instrumental approach that offers the opportunity for enhanced appreciation and attention to nature's value.

Note: Article Brady E, Univ Lancaster, Furness Coll, Dept Philosophy, Lancaster LA1 4YG, ENGLAND

Keyword(s): disinterestedness; aesthetic value; environmental aesthetics; natural beauty

Zurück | Weiter